Comments on: Catherine Hardwicke FIRED from New Moon: Fans of Twilight rejoice!

By: taylorlaughlinX

taylorlaughlinX — Sun, 29 Nov 2009 19:39:08 +0000

jeez i avsolutely adored Catherine

i hate the new director

By: EdwardsNewBellax

EdwardsNewBellax — Sun, 29 Nov 2009 19:38:00 +0000

i thought the first twilight movie was absolutely brilliant although i was disappointd they missed things out

they missed out jaspers talent and they fell in love 2 quick :@:@

the 2nd movie was so much better

but i didnt like tht it finished as a cliffhanger !!! cant wait to see the last one woo hoo !!

p.s TEAM EDWARD COZ JACOB DUSNT SPARKLE!!

By: sherri j.

sherri j. — Fri, 09 Oct 2009 03:27:34 +0000

i’m so glad she’s not directing new moon. twilight was so disappointing compared to the book. the story is so fantastic, and the movie was good, but she didn’t capture the relationships between bella and her father and even the relationship between bella and edward. the character development in the movie was lame.

i already have my new moon tickets preordered. can’t wait!!

By: louise

louise — Tue, 08 Sep 2009 21:03:34 +0000

i love the books they are amazing but i agree that she was awful at directing the first i know u cant put the whole book in but the important part and the reasons of the books is their love for each other , in the film there was no build up it did nt show any emotion it was like , ‘oh yeah we love each other and will always be together blah blah blah’ bella was rubbish just could nt act she is nt mature enough to take on a lead role , they dont need every part of the book just hope with new moon they get across more the emotion of it then anything else so it feels more like when you read the books

By: get the facts!

get the facts! — Fri, 03 Jul 2009 03:35:14 +0000

ok u all need 2 understand something u r blaming the movies story line on cathrine hardwick! she is the director she did not write the movie 4 goodness sake. if u think the storyline sucked blame the writters not her oh and by the way she quit they didn’t fire her. and she quit bcuz she said they wer not going 2 give her as much time as she needed 2 make the film

By: diamonds

diamonds — Mon, 29 Jun 2009 00:01:15 +0000

I think the movie was good …. not as good as it could have been but it was not horrible ! the books were better !!! i started reading them after i watched the movie and i thought it was good to actully picture the people i think the cast was amazing …. but for Catherine i think she did an ok job … but it seems like they did not have the biggest budget so if u dont have a big budget its sort of hard to put everything you want in the film …. And people should not be so harsh about criticizing her … could you have done a better job ?? probably not ….

By: brittanyl

brittanyl — Thu, 28 May 2009 17:58:24 +0000

omg i love twilight its an awesome movie the best one yet no movie can top it well maybe new moon and i love the books im glad that catherine is gone she did it no justice but it was still good but i think iit could of benn so much bdetter than ut was but i still love it so much TWILIGHT ALL THE WAY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

By: Twilight fan

Twilight fan — Mon, 25 May 2009 00:57:24 +0000

I have read all four books, plus the unfinished 5th book that is on stephenie’s blog. I have watched the movie at least 10 times. When I finished the 1st book, I immediately watched the movie. I was completely disappointed. I understand that it is hard to translate an amazing book into film, but it could have been a lot better. When I finished reading the 1st book, I couldn’t wait to see what happens in the 2nd book, when the movie was over I didn’t have the same feeling. It didn’t leave me anxious like the book did. I hope the movie New Moon captures more of the books uniqueness. So you ask why I have watched the movie 10 times if I really didn’t care for it, well I keep watching it because I hope I missed something in the movie that would make it seem more like the book, plus there are some hotties in it (that makes it worth watching). I think that Stephenie is a great author, and I hope and pray that she finishes the 5th book and keeps them going.

By: Christyna

Christyna — Thu, 21 May 2009 15:55:44 +0000

P.S. Ignore the “no” before the “sucked” lol

By: Christyna

Christyna — Thu, 21 May 2009 14:09:11 +0000

Thank GOD! I loved the first book! But the movie no sucked! People went to watch it because there were so many good looking men in this movie! But you have to be a pretty sucky director to make such a bad movie with skilled actors at your disposal! Some moments in the movie were just ridiculus! Cough Billy/Edward Stare down Cough!